Lessons from the EU and Malta’s ‘citizenship by investment’ dispute
Golden Visa - Invest Migration | June 2024
Lessons from the EU and Malta’s ‘citizenship by investment’ dispute

The EU and Malta’s ‘Cash for Citizenship’ dispute is a cautionary tale – both for poorly thought-through investment migration schemes and those who’d try to stop them. 

Last week, the European Commission’s dispute with Malta over their citizenship by investment scheme came to a head in a court case in the EU’s Grand Chamber in Luxembourg. 

In taking the step of hauling Malta to court, the EU are trying to end a decade-long policy whereby the Maltese Government have granted citizenship to foreign nationals who invest in the country above a certain threshold. The programme’s current iteration – the Malta Exceptional Investor Naturalisation Policy (MEIN) – has this threshold at €600,000, through which you gain citizenship after 36 months, and faster timeframes of up to 12 months available via a larger investment. 

The EU’s opposition to this setup is to argue that from a legal standpoint, ‘selling’ EU citizenship violates the principles of cooperation between EU member states, by making citizens of people who have no substantive connection to Malta or the EU. More widely however, it stems from the EU’s increasing aversion to investment migration programmes – a stance that unfortunately lacks understanding of the benefits that these schemes can bring. 

In my home country of Greece for instance, while we do not offer citizenship by investment, our Golden Visa programme gives investors a residency permit with many of the same benefits. This system has recently been revised to a four-tiered structure with a minimum threshold of €250,000 for commercial to residential conversions and restorations, then either €400,000 or €800,000 depending on location. Between 2021 and 2024, this scheme has earned €4.3bn for the Greek economy. Critically, this is €4.3bn that hasn’t had to come through borrowing, taxation or EU grants. 

Last week’s hearing sits in another context too – that of badly designed investment migration schemes falling by the wayside. In recent months, Spain, the Netherlands and Ireland have scrapped their Golden Visa programmes and Portugal have scaled theirs back, predominantly due to their ineffectiveness. On the other hand, Malta’s problem is that their offer is too generous to be palatable to the rest of the EU. 

The EU’s court challenge seems doomed to fail. The Maltese defence – that it is the prerogative of nations to decide who they give citizenship to – is strong, and has been reinforced by numerous historical precedents and increased vetting processes. This does not necessarily mean that the EU will give up here though, so expect their opposition to take new forms in the coming months and years, all the while causing uncertainty for prospective investors.

There are lessons to be learned for all parties from last week, regardless of the case’s outcome. For the EU, that investment migration schemes won’t be easily discarded under pressure. For its constituent nations, that there are boundaries to how far you can push the tolerance of the Commission in this sector. And for investors, that you’re better off choosing an investment migration scheme that avoids this mess in the first place.

Article written by Christina Georgaki, originally published on eureporter

Photo by Mike Nahlii on Unsplash 

Related Articles

The Golden Visa landscape is shifting in Greece and Europe. These changes tell a story of success for some, and disappointment for others. Last month, the Greek Government announced a move to a four-tiered Golden Visa system.

Golden Visa - Invest Migration | May 2024

Though media stories are decrying investment immigration, dubbing it “the end of golden visas”, the picture couldn’t be more different.

Golden Visa - Invest Migration | November 2023

As a sequel to our last article concerning the thriving Real Estate Market in Greece which presented among others the advantages of the Golden Visa Scheme, it worths highlighting the importance of the rapid processing time of the Golden Visa application. 

Golden Visa - Invest Migration | March 2023

Speaking about social globalization the world is more connected than ever due to the widespread of technology.

Golden Visa - Invest Migration | February 2023

Always wanted to move to Greece and wander around the picturesque island alleys with the view of blue domes?

Golden Visa - Invest Migration | February 2023

While the change of the limit for the Greek Golden Visa has not been established yet and it seems that no change will take place until the new year, the Greek government and the relevant ministers are studying alternative scenarios in order not to damage its popularity.

Golden Visa - Invest Migration | October 2022

The golden visa program was introduced by Law 4146/2013.

Golden Visa - Invest Migration | September 2022

The collection of the first installment by the Recovery Fund, amounting to 3,4 billion euro, towards our country, from which the amount of 1,72 billion regarding no refundable grants and the amount of 1,84 regarding loans.

Golden Visa - Invest Migration | April 2022

Removal of examination suspension and issuance of pending applications for renewal and submission of applications for renewal of residence permits of citizens of the Russian Federation and Belarus - The suspension of submission and approval of new residence permit applications is maintain

Golden Visa - Invest Migration | April 2022

You may be forgiven for assuming that the Greek and Portuguese golden visas are more or less the same. After all. both grant their holders EU residency, rely heavily on real estate investment, and follow a similar process.

Golden Visa - Invest Migration | March 2022

Following the decision of the Ministry of Immigration and Asylum for the provisions of temporary protection towards displaced Ukrainian citizens, Greek Government proceeds to the adoption of additional measures of humanitarian sensitivity as aid to Ukrainian ci

Golden Visa - Invest Migration | March 2022

Residency by investment (RBI) is a two-way venture. There is the immigration aspect, which in the case of Greece’s Golden Visa is the residency permit, and there is the investment factor, which can be quite complex and highly profitable – if done right.

Golden Visa - Invest Migration | March 2022

Following the recent undesirable developments of the Ukraine crisis, Greece proceeds to the practical support towards the displaced 

Golden Visa - Invest Migration | March 2022

By the adoption of the New Immigration Code in 2014, Greece entered the Golden Visa sector dynamically constituting one of the principal choices for investment immigration candidates.

Golden Visa - Invest Migration | March 2022

The upturn of Greek economy is confirmed once more by the national bank of Greece, according to the relevant data indicating the “vertical” increase of foreign direct investments in Greece for 2021, even in comparison to the pre-COVID era.<

Golden Visa - Invest Migration | February 2022

by Christian Henrik Nesheim


How do you spend your weekends?

Golden Visa - Invest Migration | February 2022

Following the idleness of the investment community recorded during 2020 due to the pandemic, 2021 seems to show improving statistics from foreign investors in Greece.

Golden Visa - Invest Migration | February 2022
How Can We Help You